My Romenesko verdict: no harm, no foul


Media columnist Jim Romenesko--who was scheduled to depart his full-time position at the Poynter Institute at the end of the year, anyway--vacated it abruptly yesterday after his boss, Julie Moos, publicly criticized his "incomplete" methods of attributing other journalists' copy in his summaries of their work.

For those who haven't followed the story--and I don't blame you if you haven't, because it's so inside baseball it's inside the laces of the ball--Romenesko has been writing a Web-based cheat sheet about the news business since 1999. The column, which the non-profit Poynter Institute picked up in 2000, has been an indispensable destination for journalists and civilians interested in the media. (Interests declared: Romenesko has cited my work many times since 1999. For the last 10 weeks, Poynter has been paying me to participate in weekly, hour-long Web chats with readers.)

In declaring a "pattern of incomplete attribution," Moos pointed to a recent example from Romenesko's work in which he ran whole sentences from a Chicago Tribune story in his summary of it without placing the words in quotation marks or block quotation to indicate its exact provenance.

Romenesko's style was not Poynter's style, Moos wrote, commenting that, "One danger of this practice is that the words may appear to belong to Jim when they in fact belong to another."

Like Moos, I think that Romenesko should have placed in quotation marks (or block quotations) copy taken from stories he summarized. When I've worked as an editor, that has been my standard. As a writer, I follow the same code. If anything, I overdo the quotation-marks thing. You're free to criticize the windy way Moos explains Poynter's policy and its inquiry, but as the editor she's well within her rights to set attribution rules.

(Continued on Reuters.)

Latest in Columns

My Romenesko verdict: no harm, no foul Nov. 11, 2011

Who gets to be anonymous? Nov. 9, 2011

Unoccupy Google Reader Nov. 3, 2011

Columns Archive

Latest Posts

The Rise of the Right to Know December/January, 2016 Book Reviews

Freedom of Speech: Mightier Than the Sword May 5, 2015 Book Reviews

All the Truth Is Out: The Week Politics Went Tabloid Oct. 31, 2014 Book Reviews

Hell Before Breakfast: America's First War Correspondents Making History and Headlines, from the Battlefileds of the Civil War to the Far Reaches of the Ottoman Empire June/July/Aug 2014 Book Reviews

Secrets and Leaks: The Dilemma of State Secrecy March/April 2014 Book Reviews

Diaries: George Orwell Sept/Oct/Nov 2012 Book Reviews

My Romenesko verdict: no harm, no foul Nov. 11, 2011 Columns

Who gets to be anonymous? Nov. 9, 2011 Columns

Unoccupy Google Reader Nov. 3, 2011 Columns

The Tripster in Wolfe's Clothing March/April 2006 Magazine Work

The State of Media Criticism; Getting Sacked Sept. 5, 2011 TV/Radio

Suck Amok Nov. 1, 1995 Miscellany

Me & My Monkey Jan. 13, 1995 Extra!